Does an employee sacrifice childcare vouchers during maternity leave?
31 / 03 / 2016
There has been a recent decision in the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) in relation to continuing childcare vouchers during maternity leave which may be of interest to those of you who provide these vouchers by way of a salary sacrifice scheme.
Entitlements during maternity leave
During ordinary maternity leave (which is the first 26 weeks of leave) and additional maternity leave (the further period of 26 weeks), an employee is entitled to all their usual terms and conditions of employment, including benefits, save for those terms which relate to “remuneration”, which is defined as wages or salary.
Unless an employer provides for something more favourable, an eligible employee’s remuneration is decreased to the statutory amounts, which are:
- First six weeks: the “earnings-related rate” (90% of the employee’s “normal weekly earnings”) or the “prescribed rate” (currently £139.58) whichever is higher;
- Following 33 weeks: the prescribed rate or the earnings-related rate, whichever is lower
- Remaining 13 weeks: unpaid
Many employers make childcare vouchers schemes available to their workforce, usually by way of salary sacrifice. Due to the significant tax savings, these schemes prove popular with employers and employees.
However, how should childcare vouchers be treated during maternity leave when there is no salary to sacrifice? Should they be treated as “remuneration” and therefore suspended, or are they a non-cash benefit, which would need to continue?
Following guidance from HMRC first published in 2008, the general consensus was that these vouchers fell into the latter category and so employers needed to keep paying them during maternity leave. But, this came at an additional cost to the employer; as it is not possible to make deductions from any statutory pay entitlement, this meant that employers had to cover the cost of the childcare vouchers during maternity leave as they were unable to make the equivalent deduction from the employee’s wages as they would have prior to any period of maternity leave.
The EAT decision
In the recent case of Peninsula Business Services v Donaldson, Ms Donaldson claimed it was discriminatory to suspend these vouchers during her maternity leave. At first instance, the Tribunal agreed. However, Peninsula Business Services appealed this decision. The EAT overturned the Tribunal’s decision, saying that childcare vouchers should be classed as “remuneration”. It follows that they do not have to be provided during maternity leave.
The EAT said that childcare vouchers weren’t really a salary “sacrifice” as such, rather a diversion of salary to a third party and therefore should be considered to be remuneration. Otherwise, said the EAT, the employee is getting a windfall at the expense of the employer, which presumably was not the intention of Parliament.
What does this mean for you?
This will come as welcome news to those who provide childcare vouchers through a salary sacrifice scheme. But before you breathe a sigh of relief, we report this decision with some caution; it is likely to be challenged.
The safest approach is to continue to provide these vouchers during maternity leave, but if this is a practice you are looking to change, you should:
- Establish how childcare vouchers are provided. Vouchers provided outside a salary sacrifice scheme will still be classed as a non-cash benefit and so should continue to be provided during maternity leave.
- Check your policies to determine whether there is in fact an obligation to continue to provide childcare vouchers during maternity leave and whether there’s a risk that this is a contractual right.
- Don’t simply discontinue childcare vouchers for those on maternity leave without considering the implications first.
- Any changes should be made to shared parental leave and adoption leave policies, as the same principles apply.
There’s bound to be further case law following this decision and we will keep you updated. If you’d like to discuss how this decision impacts on your business, do not hesitate to contact a member of the employment team.