• Article
  • Nov 19, 2026

The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill – the end of leasehold?

Today, 19 November 2026, Angela Rayner, the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government, and Matthew Pennycook, the Minister of State for Housing and Planning, published the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill (“CLRB“) which sets out the government’s plan to transform the experience of homeownership. The Labour Party’s 2024 manifesto had stated that “for far too many leaseholders, the reality of home ownership falls woefully short of the dream they were promised”. In a press release published today Mr Pennycook stated, “This Bill marks a historic step towards dismantling the feudal leasehold system.”

Share this page: LinkedIn X

The end of an era

The leasehold system is not perfect by any means but that is not to say it is an unfair hangover of feudalism. Rather, it serves as a model that provides an exceptionally clear framework in which individuals can both own a home and share collective responsibility for common areas. The CLRB constitutes a major step towards revamping a model that has long-underpinned property law in England and Wales since the days of the William the Conqueror.

History repeating itself?

Commonhold is not a new concept, it has been previously overwhelmingly rejected by the free market. It was introduced in England and Wales in 2004 to allow flat owners to own their properties as if a freeholder whilst managing communal areas through a commonhold association. However, low adoption meant commonhold properties are currently very much a minority and leasehold dwellings dominate the residential market. Figures from the Ministry of Housing, Communities & Local Government 2024 Commonhold White Paper put the number of individual commonhold units across England and Wales at less than 200 (in fewer than 20 commonhold developments). In contrast, an initial press release of yesterday states that there are an estimated 5 million leasehold homes across England and Wales. The previous widespread rejection of the commonhold model can be interpreted as an indicator of the success and benefits of the leasehold system.

What’s new?

The CLRB will introduce a cap on ground rents (initially £250 a year and then a peppercorn after 40 years). This builds on The Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022 and ensures that existing leaseholders also see a benefit. This may be attractive to the average flat owner but it does interfere with the rights of the owner of the wider building, the freeholder, and the reasonable assumptions they would have made at the time of acquiring the building as an investment. Investor freeholders would have purchased the building on the basis that their investment would produce a steady income via ground rents. Introducing legislation with a retrospective effect carries with it a real risk of damaging the real estate market and investor confidence in property as an asset class. Increased risk in the sector could result in future investors of blocks of flats demanding higher returns to commit capital and higher financing costs could translate into a negative for the average flat owner i.e., if a block of flats is more expensive to build in the first place, will the initial purchase price of the flats be more expensive? We suspect so.

The CLRB will abolish the system of leasehold forfeiture. This is a process whereby a breach of a covenant of a lease can result in the lease being terminated. This is often considered as a draconian remedy. The loss of this process does not mean breaches will not be enforced. Instead, there will be a court supervised system with the remedy tailored to the breach via a lease enforcement claim. While supporters of the CLRB will argue the resulting remedial orders and orders for sale constitute a more proportionate approach, the reality is that forfeiture is a mechanism that is rarely used in practice. When it is used, it operates as a useful method of last resort to help landlords ensure that leaseholders comply with the terms of their lease. This is particularly important in residential developments where persistent breaches, including non-payment or anti-social behaviour by a leaseholder, can have a negative effect on the other leaseholders living in the development.

What’s the aim of the CLRB?

The CLRB’s aim is for commonhold to become the default tenure. To that end, the use of leasehold for most new flats will be banned. There is a firm intention at this stage to ensure existing leaseholders are not left behind. The CLRB will seek to achieve this by making it far easier for leaseholders to convert to commonhold. Currently, consent is required from the freeholder, 100% of leaseholders in the building (and their lenders). The CLRB looks to lower the threshold of leaseholder consent to 50%. Therefore, there could be leaseholders who are ultimately obliged to join their neighbours in a novel legal model, which includes the responsibility of either co-managing a residential development or engaging a suitable management company. They would have bought their flat in a structure understood by investors, management companies, banks and society at large. However, the implications of using this new form of commonhold are as yet unknown.

It is the case that leaseholders only own their flat for a certain period of time and those who own the freehold interest own the actual land the flats sits on forever. However, the reality is leasehold property interests are still long-term and can be extended, mortgaged and sold. They are well-understood by freeholders, leaseholders and banks.

The potential difficult reality

The CLRB’s supporters argue freeholders or managing agents can impose high service charges and face little accountability over the ways they spend the money. However, mismanagement and accompanying disputes can take place within any structure for dealing with property interests. The reality is the costs associated with owning a flat are still going to exist. By way of example, an old roof is still an old roof and repair will still need to be paid for and the costs will always be borne by those who own the flats. A commonhold system does not in any way guarantee an improvement on the status-quo.

Under the current leasehold structure, the landlord organises and procures works before recovering these costs via a service charge. Under the commonhold structure, the commonhold association will seek input from many people, each who may have their own objectives. Will the residents of the lower floors argue that only the top floor residents are responsible for the roof? Those lower floor residents would surely outnumber the top floor residents. Suppose an adequate repair could be carried out and so too could a much more thorough and long-lasting repair costing double? Who will decide? Will the cheaper option be the default solution? If it is, will the quality of multi occupied residential buildings decline over time as a consequence? Can potentially hundreds of flat owners in a large residential development realistically come together to successfully and harmoniously manage the development? For example, directors of the commonhold association will need to secure agreement on expenses via a vote on the annual budget. The potential issue that springs to mind is what happens if a budget fails to pass, or if a budget is passed which is neither fair, reasonable nor proportionate? Clearly, this may be unsatisfactory if essential and costly maintenance is required.

What could have been addressed?

In a world where the Building Safety Act 2022 (“BSA“) is passing more and more costs onto landlords, the bigger issue that needs to be addressed is what happens when the entity that owns the building to which each lease is subject has no money? The CLRB and commonhold will not help here.

The Court of Appeal held this week (17 November 2026) in Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.1 Ltd v De Valk that the leaseholder protections of paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 to the BSA apply to unsafe cladding even where the works do not concern a “relevant defect” as defined by the BSA. Whilst this may be good news at one level for the individual flat owners of Centre Point House (and any other building to which the same analysis could apply), the costs for the required remediation need to be paid by someone. If a landlord has no money and goes into insolvency, more headaches will ensue. The BSA does enable costs to be passed around to others within the corporate group (via Building Liability Orders (BLOs) or Remediation Contribution Orders (RCOs)) but that requires court orders, time and cost. If there are no others who could be made to contribute and/or the directors of the landlord cease business for fear of a fraudulent trading claim, all owners of flats may wish that the reform of the system concentrated on greater protections in the event the landlord no longer exists.

And so

The CLRB is being held up as a win for flat owners, the leaseholders, but it risks creating uncertainty for investors, funders and the average owner. It involves moving away from a system that has long fostered the efficient establishment and management of large residential developments. Whilst the CLRB does seek to address some of the issues with the current commonhold regime, it still does not promise a system that is superior to the leasehold one that has been so widely and successfully adopted. Bold promises have been made regarding its outcome. We fear the reality may be a disappointment.

This article is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or a comprehensive statement of the law. Specific legal advice should always be sought in relation to individual circumstances.

Meet the team:

View more